It goes without saying that The Bell Jar is a very impactful and depressing book. I remember on my trip to New Orleans when Ms. Denos saw me start reading it she was like "oh no you're reading The Bell Jar... it's a really disturbing book just letting you know. All of Sylvia Plath's works are so depressing". With less than 50 days left of my Uni career, I have plenty of things to be depressed about that are inevitable -- blog posts are one of the few things that I have complete control over. Hence, I want to focus on the one part of the book that made me happy for longer than 5 minutes, and that is Esther's relationship with Dr. Nolan (there are actually a couple parts that made me smile, but most of those periods of happiness are quickly interrupted by themes of self-destruction, mental unsteadiness, and just general brutality).
Before we talk about Dr. Nolan though, we have to talk about Esther's previous physician -- Dr. Gordon. To Esther, he can be seen as Buddy in the future -- a rich, handsome doctor with a complete and happy family and everything is just perfect with butterflies flapping around and fireflies shimmering in the background (ok the last part is a little exaggerated but you get the point). As soon as Esther sees all of this, she instantly knew that Dr. Gordon was gonna do smack to her depression,
"But Doctor Gordon wasn't like that at all. He was young and good-looking, and I could see right away he was conceited.
Doctor Gordon had a photograph on his desk. . . It was a family photograph, and it showed a beautiful dark-haired women. . . smiling out over the heads of two blond children. . . Doctor Gordon was trying to show me right away that he was married to some glamorous woman and I'd better not get any funny ideas.
Then I thought, how could this Doctor Gordon help me anyway, with a beautiful wife and beautiful children and a beautiful dog haloing him like the angels on a Christmas card?" (Plath 129)
So maybe butterflies and fireflies aren't that big of a stretch.
To be honest, initially I thought that Esther was over-reacting. Like common, it's just a picture -- you even admitted that you weren't completely sure why the photo made you furious. Two lines later though, I was totally on your side when he said,
"Suppose you try and tell me what you think is wrong" (Plath 129).
Like BITCH PLEASE we call you "doctor" for a fucking reason if the patient knew what the hell was wrong you wouldn't have a job you --
and right then a line that previously didn't trigger me before,
"Your mother tells me you are upset" (Plath 128).
made me even more ferocious. What sounded like "hmm I want to help you. What's up?" turned into "her der der (<-- those are douchy people sounds) aww did something happen to you poor girl" that I responded with "yea no shit something happened she came to you for a fucking reason what you think that she just wants to have her mother pay 25 bucks and your so she can feel miserable in your office?" She hasn't slept for a week or showered for three like um hello what's up with you and you're empty words like I know you don't actually care for her but common you're getting paid here at least try to pretend to be listening (and not ask basic introductory questions over and over again? I mean at least write some stuff down). "her der der" ELECTROSHOCK MY A** at least do it properly dipshit.
She walks out of your office and reads a flyer about attempted suicides. Good going you --
I mean damn I want to become a doctor but if I'm gonna be anything like you imma transfer over to the cs department like screw this shit, but thankfully Dr. Nolan comes and saves the respect I hold for physicians.
Ah right Dr. Nolan. This post was supposed to stay positive. My bad.
Well first off, Dr. Nolan actually pays attention. She learns about Esther's experiences, deduces that her depression stems from sexist propaganda (as discussed in class), which she assures her is bullshit by connecting her own life to her (about how women don't need to be under men, like how she is a doctor and not a housewife or whatever the notion of what women should do at that time is). See that's what psychiatrists are supposed to do. Oh also she actually performs electroshock properly and makes Esther feel better.
I guess what essentially made me happy was that Dr. Nolan was a proper caring doctor, and made up for Gordon (who was more of an insult to me as an aspiring physician than a doctor) being a shitlord. All the complaints I had earlier about Gordon... well I don't have those complaints for Dr. Nolan. And yes I'm dropping the "Dr." for Gordon on purpose. Who gives a damn if you have an M.D. -- if you're a dickhead who doesn't care about people you're a dickhead who doesn't care about people and that's all there is to it.
I would describe Nolan as somewhere between a doctor, a surrogate-mother figure, and a cool professor/therapist, in terms of her influence on Esther. Part of her work is traditional "doctor" fare--prescribing medication, supervising treatments--but as we discussed, she also counsels Esther and serves as a friend (to the point that Esther uses the word "love" to describe her feelings for her, a word she doesn't use anywhere else in the novel), and by setting her up with birth control and denouncing the propaganda Esther has been fed by her mother and Mrs. Willard as "propaganda!" she gives her the courage to contemplate an alternative to the mainstream ideals for a woman in her culture. Dr. Nolan's importance in the novel really can't be overestimated.
ReplyDeleteThe appearance of Dr. Nolan certainly provided a refreshing break from the horrors of Esther's previous experiences with Gordon. The connection formed between the two women is one of the most important parts of Esther's recovery, as she finally has someone who both understands her and cares about her.
ReplyDeleteDoctor Gordon was scary, a scary man. I think that this character, although i'm sure he's real in many ways too, really solidified Esther's view of the world. Nolan on the other hand presents a totally new world of sex, jobs, and freedom.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDelete